05 July 2006

Edubuntu Live CD

Edubuntu is the education/terminal server member of the Ubuntu family of Linux operating systems. It is designed for the education market and includes a server based computing component. The TS portion is aimed at the classroom environment running within the school LAN. More on the TS portion later.

Edubuntu is available in three flavors. On their web site they list;

"PC (Intel x86) desktop CD
For almost all PCs. This includes most machines with Intel/AMD/etc type processors and almost all computers that run Microsoft Windows. Choose this if you are at all unsure.

Mac (PowerPC) desktop CD
For Apple Macintosh G3, G4, and G5 computers, including iBooks and PowerBooks.

64-bit PC (AMD64) desktop CD
For computers based on the AMD64 or EM64T architecture (e.g.,Athlon64, Opteron, EM64T Xeon). It is not necessary for all (most) processors made by AMD -- only their 64 bit chips."

These are "Live" CD ISO images that let your load the Edubuntu OS without installing the OS on to your system. Experience what the user will see and hear without committing to an installation. I loaded the x86 and 64-bit "Live" versions on the appropriate platforms without a problem.

Edubuntu does not claim to be the ultimate Terminal Server solution. It offers a clean and simple desktop from a server to a computer that meets the minimum requirements listed below and as posted on Edubuntu's web site.

"The minimum requirements for a thin client computer is a Pentium II with 48MB RAM and a 2MB display card. Recommended specifications is at least a Pentium II/300 with 64MB RAM and a 4MB display card. You will also need a method to boot over the network. Most newer mother boards (and network cards) have built-in PXE software that allows you to boot from the network. If it doesn't, you can create a network boot floppy or CD from http://rom-o-matic.net. Keep in mind that you need to enable PXE emulation when creating the boot media."

I tested the boot process using rom-o-matic, native PXE boots on several computers from multiple vendors, and a thin client device, without a problem. This is not however, a low bandwidth solution. This solution needs to run on a local area network. One hundred megabit switches or greater may be required for all but the smallest installations.

Once the "Live" CD is loaded, it places an icon on the desktop that will load the OS on to you local drive. That is good. The bad news it does not load the Terminal server portion of the OS. To see and follow the actual setup instructions as presented in the "Getting Started" document you will have the use the Alternate installation CD that is available on the same down load site. Just look a little lower on the download page. Download and burn the ISO image as listed in the "Getting Started" document, then boot from that alternate image.

The default installation assumes that you are setting up a new installation. And that you are using a 192.168.0 address scheme with this machine as a DHCP server for this network segment. For my testing I used another addressing scheme and the "Getting Started" document explains how to change the address range and restart the DHCP server. There is additional documentation if you want to add sound, have mixed computing architectures, and/or use another DHCP server.

What about printing? For me it is very nice. Had the choice of using SAMBA or CUPS. Choose both and they both worked just fine. I may be one of the few sites in the world that has an HP printer that works with all the Linux systems but none of the Microsoft OSes on site. What printer am I using for the tests?

Is Edubuntu ready for large installations, probably not. Being limited to a single server, there is no scalability. The one server goes down and you have a problem. I stored personal data on a Network Storage Device that was accessible by multiple operating systems and could go from one OS to another and keep my personal data. But this is contrary to the idea of a simple solution for education (or any other market segment). Overall however, it is a very promising solution. A few more steps on the development path and it will be a very viable option in the Server Based Comptuing market.

This blog is about Server Based Computing and not about the applications that are executed on the SBC platforms. However, since it Edubuntu is directed at the education market I will make a comment. Wish I had this option when I was in school. Even as a stand alone OS, it is worth looking at as a desktop OS.

Families that have trouble maintaining 2, 3, or 4 personal computers at home, might find this a welcomed solution. Has instant messaging, web access, and open office suite for creating documents and presentations. The repository of available applications is extensive. However, try downloading a program that requires an installation and your are not the administrator! Not today.

As a foot note to large organizations contemplating Server Based Computing for browser based applications or SOA, you might want to book mark another of Ubuntu's family members, Xubuntu.org. Theoretical capacity with existing technology is over 400 users per server. If it can achieve 25% of that it would be very interesting. The Terminal Server portion is not there yet, but it is included in the install as an option.

Was curious as to how to pronounce Xubuntu. Found three choices.

"ZOO-bun-tu", "ZOO-boon-too", and "ZOO-boon-tuu". They all agreed on "ZOO".

Until the next post,

Steve



13 June 2006

Konect Virtual Image NFR LIVE Evaluation DVD

Konect is a serverware solution from “Desktopsites, Inc” and the company web site is www.desktopsites.com.

Konect is targeting the SMB market that have 5 to 500+ Server Based Computing users. Konect seamlessly publishes applications ,web services and other resources with secure internal and external access.

Quoting from "get Konected";

“Konect makes sense when your business...

  • has staff that work from home, on the road or are in multiple locations
  • is in need of ways to give employees real-time access to applications &
    information
  • is looking for service service to customers
  • would like reduce IT licensing, management and support costs”

To keep the solution simple, icons for published resources are placed on the Windows desktop and in the Konect Launcher in the system tray. To the user community these resources can be utilized using the same skills as if they were local resources.

The solution has *Konect Management Console* that permits the server based computing solution administrator to manage the environment directly for only those users that require the Konect solution. Industry documentation calls this leveraging the RDP protocol. In other words, building upon the Microsoft remote desktop protocol to provide additional functionality.

Konect is deployed on Windows 2000 or 2003 Servers that utilize Active Directory. Konect has a Secure Gateway that uses ticketing to provide secure external connections. The company documentation is straight forward and advises you upfront that this solution will NOT work on the Small Business version of Microsoft server. The getting started documentation for the standard evaluation product is one of the best prepared (if not the best) presentation for new administrators wanting to review Sever Based Computing options that I have read.

The Konect Virtual Image NFR Demo DVD guide has about 30 lines of instructions for installing the VMware Player, image, and the remote client. It took me about 30 minutes to set up successfully (first attempt) the “Live” DVD demo. If you are familiar with VM Player then subtract 5 to 10 minutes. It took me a little additional time to understand the server inside a server concept and how to change the focus between the two servers. The virtual Network Interface also added a few minutes of thought time but was quickly resolved.

The test server I used was a Sempron based system with 1 GB of ram. The Demo DVD setup documentation suggests 1 GB but recommends 2 GB on on P3 at 800 MHz or higher. The client side should be 500 MHz with 128MB of Ram. The Microsoft NT/2000/XP clients require Java Run Time Environment 1.5.0 or higher.

Once the VMware Player is up and running, go to the client machine, open the browser and key in the IP address of the VM server that you created during the VM Player installation. Konect will detect the presence of JVM 1.5.0 and load the the client side software. If it does not detect JVM, it will present a simple instillation of JVM. You are asked if you want create shortcuts, answer and then select finish.

A log on screen is presented and you may key in one of two user names and passwords that are provided. You now have a demonstrable version of Konect that does not require a dedicated server. The Java client can be removed by logging out and simply click on the Konect icon in the tray and select “clean Java cache”. Gone.

In summary, the purpose of a “live” demo version is to provide an interactive presentation that will permit an intelligent decision to move on the next product or go into more detail with this product by installing the full evaluation copy. Konect has confidence that if you interact with their “Live” version you can make that decision. What evaluators know is the hardest thing to do is find the time to load and test. There is always something more pressing to do than load an evaluate a vendors evaluation product. Konect lowers that threshold to less time that it takes to go to lunch. Want to lose weight, pass on lunch and evaluate Konect.

The “live” DVD Demo is a relatively new offering from www.desktopsites.com. Contact support@desktopsites.com and request a DVD demo disk.

Until the next post,

Steve

31 May 2006

Server Based Computing reviews. Funeral or Wedding?

Personally, I find many reviews boring. They read more like an obituary than a wedding announcement. There is a listing of the product features (accomplishments), surviving relatives (vendors, channel partners), time and date for the funeral (visit us in Booth XX, East Upper Mezzanine, Bldg. 5 , convention of the month), and where to send flowers (buy NOW on-line).

Reviews should be about new products, new services, new gadgets. A new beginning, just like a wedding. The evaluation format will start with the SBC vendors target market (invited guest list). The product features (dowry) and contact information (wedding registry). I will then ad my commentary regarding the evaluation package (The Invitation). You then decide if you are a member of the guest list and request your own invitation, or if not, just choose to crash the wedding and read the rest of the evaluation review (account of the wedding hosted on the society page).

Perhaps a better analogy would be peer review of a scientific paper. Start with a hypothesis (target market solution), the laboratory environment and experiment design (evaluation product), and brief summary of salient facts (hits target market?) with the entire research findings appended as an attachment (you decide for yourself). Do scientific papers have an open bar after they are published? I will go with the wedding theme.

Remember KISS. Keep It Simple Steve.

Until the next post,

Steve

28 May 2006

Let's go Live with Server Based Computing evaluations

Two out of the nine vendors have almost "Live" evaluation copies. They are Konect from DTS and Edubuntu, the education cousin of Ubuntu. Each has the ability to be loaded without the standard install routine.

Konect by DTS (desktopsites) uses the VMware Player for Windows and has a "Konect Virtual Image DVD" for the player. The installation is straight forward and went on my vanilla AMD64 without a problem.

Edubuntu has a "Live" 64 version and it also came up on boot as it should. There is however a
small problem with the "Live" version and I will cover that in more detail later.

First up, Konect from DTS, followed by Edubuntu. The remaining seven will then fall into line.

Until the next post,

Steve

16 May 2006

And now there are nine SBC vendors

-------------------------------------------------------

Nine SBC vendors responded to my request for information. Also, was granted an evaluation copy or it was available to the public to download from their website.

The vendors are:

1: Edubuntu
2: ERICOM
3: GraphOn
4: HOBLink
5: Jetro Platforms
6: Konect
7: Microsoft 2003 TS
8: NoMachine
9: Propalms TSE

Next step in the process is to decide what order to start evaluating the SBC products. Alphabetically has always been accepted with little or no objections. How about we start with vendors that offer a “Live” CD/DVD version for evaluating their product? One more list and then to the start line!

Until the next post,

Steve

18 April 2006

The "S" words for Server Based Computing

In my first post I asked the question what is the future role of SBC. Is it more of the same but with more added on? Or is there something different over the horizon?

In either case, there is a minimum set of values that should be addressed and displayed by the SBC and thin client vendors. These values are often implied, or lost, in the "techno mumbo jumbo" listings of their product features or mission statements. The buyers technical staff, in most cases, are the decision makers and they love the technical information and that is also their responsibility. But, somewhere up the decision tree, there may be someone that may not be as technically savvy as the IT staff and they have the responsibility to sign off on the project. If I were them, I would be asking some questions and they all have the letter "S" in common.

Safe and Secure

Is the proposed project solution safe and secure for the entire enterprise? Not enough that it meets the demands and specifications of the project objective, but it must be integrated into a larger IT infrastructure.

Sound

The 1913 Webster dictionary definition of "Sound" is " Whole, unbroken, unharmed, free from flaw, or decay, perfect of the kind...". Perhaps too much to ask of a vendor, but please do.

Scalable

It has been said that an organization is either growing or dying. Is the SBC vendors product solution able to grow with the needs of the organization? Are the barriers to achieving scalability a function of physical limitations of the hardware, software, architecture or a decision to segment a market as defined by the marketing group?


SIMPLE


How simple? No more complex than is required to meet the project solution and scalability requirements. For those of you that are very much into mastering the complexity of SBC, enjoy the possibilities if your organization approves. However, one only needs to visit a public or private help forum to realize that many organizations have over purchased a SBC solution or under planned for the implementation. Either case, there is a waste of resources and productivity.

Still waiting on a few vendors to respond to the survey, and hope fades with each sunset that they will respond. Therefore, I will evaluate those products that I am able to evaluate using my letter "S" criteria. Vendors that could not, or choose not to, respond to a generic request for information would not be as "Sound" as the vendor that hosted an hour long "one on one" webinar demonstrating how well their products meet the "S" criteria.

Until the next post,

Steve

04 April 2006

Survey Results for Server Based Computing vendors

Preliminary results for the survey of Server Based Computing vendors are in and counted. The results are so mixed up I am going to do it over again with less thought. Forgot the acronym KISS. Keep It Simple Steve.

My requests for information confused many of the SBC vendors. I asked them where do they see themselves positioned in the Server Based Computing market. Do you have a road map for the future of your product(s)? I received no answers to either of those questions.

However, a request for general information through the vendors web site produced different results. In two cases, from the time I selected the Submit button until I was contacted, was UNDER 10 Minutes!!!! Not days, not hours, but minutes. And they provided more than enough quality information that conveyed to me they are capable of being a good technology partner. The rest of the results were as diverse as the colors in a rainbow.

The president of one company told me he did not have an evaluation copy of his product. If I wanted to see the capabilities of his product in my environment I had to purchase the product. And the web site looked like he had one of the best solutions on the market. I will never know if that is true.

Another vendor and I exchanged phone messages for about a week. Finally we connected and discussed the history of their product and their current offering. He promised the send me updated information as well as the FTP address to download their current product to test. Even told me that he HAD pressed the send button. Nothing. Still waiting for that email he sent five days ago. Perhaps not a good technology partner?

One of the best responses was from a vendor that contacted me within a day and provided me with a link to an on line web demonstration page not yet published. It will be, in my humble opinion, the new gold standard for an On Line SBC demonstration. Then, followed up with an offer to give me an on line tour of their management suit They have that much confidence in their product and I look forward to the interactive demonstration later this week.

I would like to find out if the good responses from vendors were the results of good actions by the vendors or just that I made a simple request for sales information. Will once again, with the goal to level the playing field, request via their web information page basic sales information. We then will have a better idea if it was the vendors good business practices or me asking the right questions that made for a good contact.

Until the next post,

Steve

07 March 2006

On Line Demos for Server Based Computing

The emails are going out to the SBC vendors listed in the left column asking them about their products. And I have received some return emails. Several including names of real people within the organization. One vendor had a technical representative ring me as they promised they would do. But that is not today's topic. We will come back to that topic on a later date.

As I started going down the list in the left column from 2 to T looking for contact names, I came across a blog within the Sun Development Network maintained by Greg Murray. In his blog he has a quote "A demo is worth 1000 words". How many vendors are confident of their products usability that they will allow a village idiot like me to test their product on line, in real time, via the Internet? Let's go surfing.

The test machine is an old IBM PIII with 512 MB of ram. The Bios has been updated to the 11/5/03 version. The operating system is Xandros 3.0.2 Deluxe with a build date of 2005-06-23 11:43. The browser is Firefox 1.0.7.

Lets start with Greg's blog. You can browse over to SDN using the AJAX link in the left column. Select Blog Central, then Choose Greg's blog. Or click here if you are in hurry to get to Murray. Technically this demo would not pass over my threshold as a demo of product usability. But I did borrow his 1000 word line and it was his blog that initiated the idea of searching for on line demos while waiting for SBC vendors to respond to my request for information.

There are four links to servlets for testing. Autocomplete, Basic Progress Bar, Realtime Form Validation, and Refreshing Data. Perhaps a corollary to "A demo is worth 1000 words" is a "journey of a 1000 miles begins with a single step". With the exception of software development. You have to go about 685 miles before you run your first real build. Of course accounting now notes that you two thirds complete and informs marketing of their calculation. Marketing creates a press release that says development is more than two thirds done and expect a product release next quarter.

There is also a video "AJAX in Action". Warning, no car chases even though the sound track leads you to expect one.

Next on the list is Citrix. Citrix has "Auto Run Demos" and on line product tests. You can use the link in the left column to browse over to Citrix or click here to jump to their demos.

The topics include:

* Citrix Access Suite 4
* Citrix Presentation Server 4
* Citrix Password Manager 4
* Citrix & Courion Enterprise Single -Sigh-on and User Provisioning Solution
* Calculate Savings with the ROI Calculator
* Access Infrastructure for Government
* Access Infrastructure for Healthcare
* Access Infrastructure for Manufacturing
* Access Infrastructure for Education
* Access Infrastructure for Financial Services
* Introduction to Citrix SmoothRoaming
* Introduction to Citrix IT Consolidation

There are a few hardware requirements listed to view the Auto Demos. The presentations are very good and present the Citrix solutions. The product tests are located at the bottom of the demo screen and may be selected by company and product. May require a Java download.

ERICOM's demo page contains access to Windows and browser based applications. Click "here" to go directly to their demo page. The demos include a Windows application as well as connections to AS/400 session. They also have Power Term Web Connect for Java Client that I used to connect a AS/400 inventory application and two Open VMS demo sessions. It should be noted that ERICOM offers free support for downloaded evaluations. Many may agree that this may be as good, if not better, than a on line demo.

GraphOn GO-Global demo is very easy to test. GraphOn has Internet Explorer and Netscape clients. You can also select the Java "no client download" for this demo. Click on the GraphOn link in the left column and then select demo at the bottom of the home page or jump to their demonstration page by clicking "here". The day I was testing, I had some difficulties loading the word application from their server. However, I located another GraphOn demo site at Resource Dynamics that was operating at 100%. Click "here" to jump to the demo registration screen or click "Resource Dynamics" to go their home page. I selected the Java option because it has a zero foot print on my machine. Their demonstration page includes real applications that they offer with GO-Global. The performance was surprisingly good.

HOBLink has a on line demo that permits you to log into MS Server 2003 with just three clicks on the mouse. In fact once you are in, just double click on the short cut to the word document "Guestbook". Make a comment and leave you name on the document. Skeptical?

First click: HOBLink in the left column.

Second click: "Test Drive HOBLink JWT Online!" It is the second line on the page.

Third Click: "Test HOBLink JWT from Windows, Linux, Sun Solaris, Apple MAC" about halfway down on the page.

Double click the shortcut to the "Guestbook" word document. Done.

I left a comment in the quest book. Wonder how long it will be there?

The last vendor on the list with a on line demo is NoMachine. In my opinion it is the best on line demo but it is not just three clicks to get there. However, this village idiot was able to successfully configure and run the on line demo on his first attempt.

The NoMachine test drive requires that a client component to be downloaded and installed. You can click on the NoMachine link in the left column to go to their Home Page. On the right of their home page is a box labeled "NX test drive". Click on this box and you are taken to the registration page. Select a country and then provide NoMachine with your name and email address. Within minutes you will receive the host name, log in name and password. Halfway home.

Just at the bottom of this screen is a link to "Step by Step" instructions. Just click on NoMachine "Here" link and your are taken to a page with "Step by Step" instructions. Select a topic and the preferred format to view. The documentation is good.

Just to right is a link to the download page. Available clients include Windows, Linux, Mac, and Solaris. I tested the Windows and Linux clients. I have some Server Based Computing experience but it still appears to me to be an easy download and install. Windows is just some mouse clicks. The Linux install is an RPM package. After the install copy the NoMachine icon to the desktop and off you go. The NoMachine documentation has a description for all the log in options. I used a KDE desktop on one test and GNOME on another.

April 10 Update. While out on the Tarantella old web site I clicked on their Live Demo link and was taken to Sun Micros Secure Global Desktop demo. Could not find the link via the SUN web site but have included the link to https://sgddemo.sun.com. No need to enter name or a password, just click on login to test the demo. Java enabled browser is required.

Finally, I added webexone to the demo list for two reasons. One, they know how to do a live demo and their product is most interesting. They claim that within 60 seconds you can be on line and testing their Web Office. Yes you can. They also have webinars and LIVE Chat to make sure you are able to use the product. I tested the live chat and a representative was on line in under a minute. The vendor offers a 30 day free trial and I am going to allocate some time over the next 30 days to better understand the product and it features. Is that not what a demo should do? Click on the link in the left column to get a 30 day trial.

There must be some reasons why the other vendors do not have an online demonstration of the product. Let us know what you think about the benefits of an on line demo or some reasons why they are not necessary.

Until the next post,

Steve

26 February 2006

What is Server Based Computing?

A line is stuck in my head, "periodically you must doubt those truths you hold to be self evident." Do not recall where it came from. When I try to resurrect the source, I smell coffee in the morning and beer at night. Must have been while in college that it got stuffed into the back corner of my brain with other information that has never seen daylight.

Perhaps it was a philosophy class, logic or symbolic logic? The name Mill jumps out at me. Then John or Stewart. I search Goggle. There is a John Stuart Mill, 1806-1873. He was in the philosophy business. Maybe it was in a philosophy class.

I like the line, but what does that have to do with Server Based Computing? For much of the past decade the SBC market has been dominated by Citrix (licensing 3.x), then with Citrix hosted atop Microsoft TS 4.0 and its successors or Microsoft TS alone. Several companies have taken a run at this market with varying degrees of success or lack of success. Why has the Microsoft/Citrix combination dominated this market segment?

Brain Madden on his web site (http://brianmadden.com/) asked the question, "Is there a viable alternative to Citrix MetaFrame"? I think there are but it begs the question "What is the future role of Server Based Computing"? Citrix knew the answer 15 years ago when it was a startup company in southeast Florida.

Is the definition of Server Based Computing still the same today as it was more than a decade ago? Perhaps not. SBC is just one arrow in an IT departments quiver of solutions. Just as technology changed arrows from shaved tree limbs and stone to exotic materials, so has the tools that IT uses to support their organizations. What are the new requirements for SBC today and tomorrow, and how well do current SBC vendors solutions meet those needs?

Don Novello, a writer and comedian that created the character "Father Guido Sarducci" also wrote several books based on the character Lazlo Toth. Lazlo wrote letters to famous people. And some of them wrote back to Lazlo. Of course this was an era before email and you could spot junk mail because it did not arrive in the mail box with a first class stamp attached to the envelope.


Unlike Don Novello whose purpose was to make humor from the responses to his letters, this blog will attempt to define SBC in its current and future role as an IT solution for organizations. We will solicit insight from users, IT administrators, financial officers, and SBC vendors and post those insights. We just might use snail mail with a first class stamp!

The first order is to define who are the vendors. I have listed many of them in the column to the left. But know that this is by no means a complete list. To help, please post the names of vendors that have not been listed that you think should be included. The only requirement is that they have an URL that we can link to their site.

Until the next post,

Steve Charles

PS. Hello John